- TCS financial statements is in Indian Rupees and reported the amounts in crores.
- Wipro's financial statement is in Indian Rupees and reported in millions. The consolidated statements in US GAAP is Indian Rupees with translations in US Dollars. The press release statement reports in Indian rupees with translations in US Dollars
- Satyam financial statements are in Indian rupees and reported in 'crores. The US Gaap statements are reported in USD and in millions.
You may read the statements from the reader's point of view:
Investor in India :
When a reader has to compare statements of TCS & Wipro, he has to convert either Satyam statement into millions or TCS into crores. Otherwise he cannot make a suitable conclusion. In India, it is a general practise that amounts are reported in lakhs/crores.
In business world, since the US dollar is dominant, he may ask his accountant to translate the financial statements in USD. Secondly, if the financial statements are in crores, then then it has to be made in millions. Then he would be able to make out sense in financial statements.
I don't think there is any Accounting Standards in India on the amounts are to be reported in millions or lakhs or crores. But I am of the opinion that
- The financial statements in India should be prepared in millions. (I should do away with my habit of thinking in 'crores !!!)
- The companies with turnover of more than Rs 10,000 million should also prepare their Balance Sheet and P&L in USD as on currency translations on last date of balance sheet.
ICAI should issue Accounting Standard on pt. 1 with due consultation with the industry and other bodies. The objective of good reporting is also comparability of financial statements.
A couple of months back, I was talking to one of my friends in US and he said that TCS is much bigger than CSC. When I told him to translate the sales to USD, then compare and he was upto a surprise. TCS is $ 2.2 billion and CSC $ 14.1 billion.
And couple of years ago, we were dicussing that Tata Motors has taken over a company for Aus $ 10 million. He said it was a great achievement for TML. When you translate the amount in Indian Rupees it 25 crores. When TML invests 25 crores, it is peanuts to them !!!
One of key factors of financial statements is comparability. I think ICAI should come out with a standard of reporting the amounts just like we have a standard metric system.
To remain updated on new posts of the blog...click on subscribe to the feed.