Skip to main content

Management Accountant as a Fit person to be a Public accountant.

1.Management accounting is concerned with the provision and use of accounting information to managers within organizations, to assist management making decisions and managerial control functions. Unlike financial accountancy information (which, for the most part, is public information), management accounting information is used within an organization and is usually confidential. Contemporary managerial accounting systems are focusing more on the activities that occur at all levels of the organization.

2.Paragraph 28 of IMAPS 1 states: “Management Accounting refers to that part of the management process which is focused on organization resource use. Thus, it refers to managerial processes and technologies that are focused on adding value to organizations by attaining the effective use of resources in dynamic and competitive contexts.”

3.According to the Chartered Institute of Management Accountants (CIMA), Management Accounting is "the process of identification, measurement, accumulation, analysis, preparation, interpretation and communication of information used by management to plan, evaluate and control within an entity and to assure appropriate use of and accountability for its resources. Management accounting also comprises the preparation of financial reports for non management groups such as shareholders, creditors, regulatory agencies and tax authorities" (CIMA Official Terminology).

Public Accounting is not defined anywhere specifically but normally understood as certification of financial statements after conducting audit of accounts maintained by the enterprise or otherwise.

Let us go through these definition one after the other:

1.provision and use of accounting information -Book-keeping and financial statements and Cost information. managers within organizations.-Internal consumption
3. assist management making decisions -MBE-management by exception(exceptional data extract for decision)

4.managerial control functions-Assisting in controls(establishment and management)-Vital information.

5. Unlike financial accountancy information - Not for public view.
6.focusing more on the activities that occur at all levels of the organization.
The crux of this definition is that the information as vital as intended is not available for public view.This is a very conservative view in todays global competitive scenario.
II----1. management process which is focused on organization resource use.

2.focused on adding value to organizations by attaining the effective use of resources. dynamic and competitive contexts.”
III-----1.the process of identification, measurement, accumulation, analysis, preparation, interpretation and communication of information used by management plan, evaluate and control within an entity .
3.and to assure appropriate use of and accountability for its resources.
4.Management accounting also comprises the preparation of financial reports for non management groups such as shareholders, creditors, regulatory agencies and tax authorities"
From all the above we find the Definition of management accountant is a comprehensive one emanating from Industrial Cost accountant in the world war period to exemplifying a diversified role of Accounting,Strategy and Management in the economic sphere.He is a good planner,record keeper, report generator,strategy formulator,and a decision support expert.
Over and above he is a good auditor ,who else could be a competitor to verifying a comprehensive work formulated by a management accountant working inside the organisation than a management accountant himself.
As CIMA rightly points out that management accounting is an all encompassing sphere including preparation of financial reports(CI MA members are recognised as Reporting Accountant in UK and EU,Though they often downplay this capability).
Management Accountant works inside the organisation as an individual gaining expertise from bottom to Top and in the course of gaining experience he becomes a key person for various stake holder,Share holder,Creditor,Regulatory agencies,tax department et al.
As Auditing is a corollary or a consequential act of verification of books and is often referred to as Public accounting the person who maintains the books inside the organisation and the person who verifies the records should have equal skill requirements and hence it is the dual role capacity exhibited by the same person when in a particular role position.
So if a management accountant is an all encompassing Accountant for the management then his position is more carved as a public accountant addressing the needs of the stakeholders.
ICAI/ICWAI act do not specify the role of Auditor in the Act ,they define a Cost accountant and Chartered accountant.Similarly the qualification of a statutory auditor is no different from that of member of ICAI(financial audit)/ICWAI(cost audit).Thus it is amply clear that Public accounting area is not intended to be seen in exclusivity by the GOI.
Worldwide for instance in Australia the Auditor is qualified for registration with the ASIC if he is a member of Three Professional bodies .In the UK the RQB recognises Auditor from among CCAB member bodies,CIMA though not a RQB(they have voluntarily abstained)they act as reporting accountant for audit exempted companies.In canada the state governments recognise members of three institutes for public accounting.Public accountant in USA is defined as -CPA. An individual who has received state certification to practice accounting. The CPA is licensed to render an Audit Opinion on the fairness of a company's financial statements. The licensing of CPAs protects the public from incompetent individuals performing substandard accounting work.
Canada has been a classic example where the state started recognising, thus long considered as internal accountants,as experts in public accounting and bestowing them with the responsibility of conducting statutory audit.The fact that financial statements have started adapting to the requirements of management by incorporating minute details in schedules and in the form of ratios,Fund flow analysis, abridged Project reports,Cost benefit product and service details vindicates the stand of the management accountants who have thus far been contributing to the primacy of the management to come out in the open and attest the work of the fellow colleagues.Stakeholders need more and more information and that legislative compulsions -demand them too and in that context and in the context of globalisation of business and transperant business deals ,it augurs well for an expert in management accountancy to attest the financial statements.
With all the above i feel no reason , except political dispensation, as to why a management accountant should not be allowed to attest financial statements.

Blog posted by RV


There is a strong feeling among the leaders(a part of them)advocating abstention from public accounting ,The reason ,they are trying to role-position the CMAs in the country in line with international norms.In this context one has to read to believe how hollow if their view when compared with international CMA bodies.There is hardly any logic to support an argument that is simmering around our leaders.As stated below Public accounting as it is called in USA is nothing but an auditing function performed by the same set of individuals who work inside the organisation(their counter part outside).Auditing is nothing but certifying the work of accounting and whoelse is in a better position to certify the same other than the same set of people who act as a counter part group.With CSR/BSC/TBL/BSBR/Management accounting principles engulfing the Globe auditing no longer remains the Forte of traditional (Balance-sheet)accountants area.ICWAI has been producing a breed of accountants all through who look beyond the P&L and Balance sheet,Those are just the window , a well dressed one -But the room was kept Dark all through in the eyes of stakeholders.The room continued to be broomed by the Cost accountant under GOI directions but in the emerging scenario of transperancy the CMAs have lit it, though dim,But it is they who are capable of attesting the Accounts generated by the businesses ,for it is from that darkness the dressing(window) started.How can some think in a Weird manner like estopping CMAs from public accounting sphere.

Popular posts from this blog

Poll : Does CIMA, UK qualification add value

Poll : Does pursuing CIMA, UK qualification add value to a member of ICWAI, India ? Vote on the poll and share your thoughts by commenting the blog. Poll: Vote here I feel that if you are a member of ICWAI and you pursue CIMA, UK qualification, you are not adding any value to your skills since you will be learning the same. Once you are qualified, you are still a Cost & Management Accountant but from UK. For an employer, I would still have same skills and training on Management Accounting. However if you pursue qualification like Company Secretary or CPA or ACCA , your skills are enhanced with the knowledge gained during training and passing of exams. After qualification, you are bound to follow the CPD programs of ICWAI and other institute. In competitive world, employer look for people with multiple skills. Which one promotes you as professional better against your name: AICWA, ACMA or AICWA, ACS or AICWA, CPA or AICWA, ACCA Widgets Regards, Santosh

Learning Curve Theory

Learning Curve Theory is concerned with the idea that when a new job, process or activity commences for the first time it is likely that the workforce involved will not achieve maximum efficiency immediately. Repetition of the task is likely to make the people more confident and knowledgeable and will eventually result in a more efficient and rapid operation. Eventually the learning process will stop after continually repeating the job. As a consequence the time to complete a task will initially decline and then stabilise once efficient working is achieved. The cumulative average time per unit is assumed to decrease by a constant percentage every time that output doubles. Cumulative average time refers to the average time per unit for all units produced so far, from and including the first one made. Major areas within management accounting where learning curve theory is likely to have consequences and suggest potential limitations of this theory. Areas of consequence: A Standard

Resistence to Change - Approaches of Kotter and Schlesinger

The Six (6) Change Approaches of Kotter and Schlesinger is a model to prevent, decrease or minimize resistance to change in organizations. According to Kotter and Schlesinger (1979), there are four reasons that certain people are resisting change : Parochial self-interest (some people are concerned with the implication of the change for themselves ad how it may effect their own interests, rather than considering the effects for the success of the business) Misunderstanding (communication problems; inadequate information) Low tolerance to change (certain people are very keen on security and stability in their work) Different assessments of the situation (some employees may disagree on the reasons for the change and on the advantages and disadvantages of the change process) Kotter and Schlesinger set out the following six (6) change approaches to deal with this resistance to cha